Two months later, and three new reviews...
Definitely, Maybe -
Yes, this is a chick flick. And no, that didn't stop me from going alone (the girl was out of the country at the time). All that being said, I was rather sure that I'd enjoy the film (I figured Ryan Reynolds and Abigail Breslin would make up for any predictability that came with the romantic comedy tag), and I really did. Much like Teen Comedies, I occasionally have a soft spot for well done Romantic Comedies, and this was one of those.
The quick plot line is that a father tells his daughter the story of how he met her mother (his soon to be ex-wife), but includes two other women in the story, so the daughter has to guess which is her mother. That was a nice little twist on the tired boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy wins girl back route that seem to litter the RomCom field. Top that off with a lovable performance by the always funny Reynolds (I like his acting skills, but he has to be put into some form of comedic role, see Blade III) and a great supporting role by Breslin (as much as I loved her work in Little Miss Sunshine, thank god they didn't try to force her into more of the film when it was a story of flashbacks to before she was conceived). The script, while still rather predictable, was clever and well done enough to make it believable and engaging, while still being funny and entertaining.
All in all it was one of the best RomComs I've seen. And as for the three love interests, I'll leave you with the mystery of guessing which one I find attractive and would have gone for.
RATING: Worth a Full Price Admission (even if they are up to $9.50 in Rochester, I can only imagine what they are in other cities), Worth a High Netflix Rental
Charlie Bartlett -
Like I have said time and again, I have a soft spot for teen comedies. Take some young actors, some old plot line (sometimes with a minor twist), an unbelievable high school locale (who really goes to school in a gothic castle and finds a date to the prom with the hottest girl in school a week before the dance?), toss in a collection of pop-punk/pop-ska songs (approximately half of which are covers) and out pops something that I will tend to watch at least once, most likely will enjoy, and almost most definitely should be embarrassed to like. Well Charlie Bartlett isn't quite there. It treads a strange middle ground. It has most of the elements of a typical TeenCom, but then it seems to also draw inspiration from other films such as Art School Confidential, Rushmore, and Igby Goes Down. Two of those three I find to be fantastic films (you can probably guess which two). However, Charlie Bartlett is closer to the third of those three. It is still entertaining, but it never quite feels at ease with itself. I guess in a way that could be a clever ploy of Jon Poll. An unsure story of teens who are unsure of themselves, but I think that would being giving the same man who made Cabin Boy, Scary Movie 3, The Beautician and the Beast, and Dunston Checks In too much credit.
Kat Dennings give a solid performance (realistic, if not a little bland) and Anton Yelchin was fabulous as Charlie (one of the better performances in a TeenCom that I've seen). And Robert Downey Jr. did a great job as well, but playing a partially washed up alcoholic seems about as much a stretch for him as playing a paranoid druggie in A Scanner Darkly was. Still you have to respect the man for being able to keep getting work and plug along (and not be dead from an OD or something by now). But apart from that everyone else seemed rather bland.
RATING: Worth a Cheap Ticket or Matinee, Worth a Middle of the Road Netflix Rental (but put the other two films I mentioned ahead of it if you're in the mood for a deeper comedy featuring teens, or get 100 Girls or 10 Things I Hate About You if you're in the mood for a TeenCom)
In Bruges -
Here is another movie that fell prey to a lack of focus. The trailers all present the film as a fun (partially) dark comedy, and while those elements are there, there is also a lot more to the film. Unfortunately, the "lot more" doesn't feel like it meshes with the dark comedy elements.
I really did appreciate the range shown by both Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson, and it was nice that they were allowed to show that off (I always knew Gleeson had it, wasn't so sure of Farrell), but throwing in the more serious stuff knocked the whole film off balance. To be fair though, the serious stuff felt a little more natural. While sitting there I felt like I was watching a bastardized version of a drama somebody had written. I couldn't help but think that originally all the zany bits were missing (save a few humorous moments here and there), but when it got to the producer/director/etc. they thought, "Hmm, these funny bits play really well. We should go back and put more in!" but didn't think of the consequences of what it would do to the flow of the film as a whole.
Maybe I was expecting too much, but what I'm trying to say is that I would have loved to see a British Comedy with some dark themes (so basically a British Comedy), or a serious piece with a few jokes thrown in for good measure (and I think that this cast was talented enough to handle either beautifully), but the combination of two just did not work in the end and I was left watching a bi-polar flick in need of some serious lithium.
RATING: Worth a Dollar Viewing, Worth a Low Netflix (but don't think you're really missing anything if you don't catch either)