So Lucas has finally done it. He's finished bastardizing the Star Wars Trilogy and completed the Hextology (or whatever it's called). Now it's my time to chime in and shift through the rumble to see what's left and where all these movies rank. Let's start from the bottom...the very very deep bottom...
#6 Episode II: Attack of the Clones
Not only does this installment have the worst title (even Ewan McGregor laughed when he heard the title, thinking it must have been a joke), it is also the worst in the series. Now I know many of you out there will disagree with me, claiming that it was bad, but still better than Episode I. You're wrong though, and here's why... First off, Episode I had a lot of hype, which was impossible to live up to. Episode II, on the other hand, came after that stinker. By then Lucas must have known full well that he had messed up, and needed badly to improve with the second, which he certainly did not. Secondly, and more importantly in my book, Episode II was just a mess. The action was lame, the light-saber duel at the end was dull (these are some of the top Jedi? Ha! Luke did a better job after like a month of training), and the only saving grace was Yoda's nice fight scene (which, by the way, I disapprove of. I mean if the dude can't even walk he can't hop around like a kangaroo, come on). Oh, and let's not forget the best part, that fantastic dialogue. I wrote better text in my 8th grade English class. Not only was the love story poorly written (and acted), not even Ewan or Christopher Lee could save the script most of the time. This movie isn't a fixer-upper, it need to be torn down and completely redone.
#5 Episode I: The Phantom Menace
This film also sucked, hardcore. But it still edges out Ep. II in my book. I've stated some of my reasoning already, but what it comes down to is rather simple. While both I and II sucked, I needs a lot less work to fix. Kill off JarJar, rework some of the Anakin stuff (like the piloting at the end, and maybe some of the pod race) and you have a workable movie. Maybe it still wouldn't be up to par with IV-VI, but it'd've been respectable. It doesn't need the whole rewrite the Ep. II does. Also, there are some saving graces in Ep. I. The light-saber battle is awsome (in my book it was the best one, short of the Clone Wars shorts), it paints a nice back story picture to the whole universe, and has some rather decent acting talent in there too.
#4 Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
Some critics argue that this one belongs in the same category as IV-VI (in fact the idiot reviewer from Rochester even went as far to put it ahead of Jedi, moron), but it doesn't belong. It is good, and a gigantic leep up from the first two, but it's not quite there. People who rank it that high are rushing to judgement and forgetting just how good the first three were. They see how much better than I or II it was and think that it must then be up with IV, V, and VI. But look again. There are plenty of holes and problems (some of them minor, some a little deeper). First off, I must applaud them for filling some problem areas and questions I had going into III (like why doesn't 3PO remember any of this?), but they missed some too (Leia remembers her mother who died during childbirth? And Luke doesn't, despite the fact that he was born first?). That's ok though, at least they tried. Let's get into the bigger problems. The dialogue is still horrid at times (at times meaning almost all of the time), even Ewan and Natalie can't save it (although the jury is still out on wether Portman is a real actress in my book). Also the CG was sub-par at times for a Lucas production (that count Doku leap in the beginning reminded me of the terrible fight scene from the Martix 2, ugh) and what's with the whole cartoony emperor? He gets wrinkled and lunny all at the same time, and it's just silly to the point of stupidity. My other glaring question (which isn't so much a production/writing thing as much as it is a story line thing) is about the Jedi themselves. It was nearly impossible to kill a Jedi in Ep. I, in fact it only happened by a Sith after a long hard battle, and they could deflect everything ever shot at them, but Jedi master after Jedi master die at the hands of a dozen clones? Maybe if they caught them by surprise, but that didn't seem to happen all that much in that sequence. Also I know that Anakin is a great fighter, but a squad (although a rather large one) and him alone take out the entire Jedi temple? It must have been pretty empty at that point. Three master Jedi also go down rather fast to Palpatine, but I can forgive this one a little. He is a Sith Lord, catches them half by surprise, and is fighting in close quarters. So I'll give them a pass on that one. Also I'd like to think that Grevious (with a 4:1 light-saber edge and a superior strength and size) could have taken Obi-wan, or at least made it a little closer. I mean he basically got his ass handed to him. In the end though Episode III stands apart from I and II, but it also stands apart (and below) the originals. Good try, but not quite enough.
#1-3 Episodes IV-VI
I can try and rate these and rank them all I want, but it seems to change daily in my mind. It's also a matter of personal taste to some extent. Do you like the originality and newness of IV, the sadness and gloominess of V, or the larger scale (and furriness) of VI? All were, and still are, fantastic movies. The cast was amazing (Ford, Hammel, and the ever hot Fisher), the writing wasn't exactly Shakespearean prose, but it was still solid, the stories were engaging, the environments and characters were beautiful and unique. It is a world that can never really be topped or duplicated. All that being said, let me give a shot at ranking them. Keep in mind that in my mind they are all so close, and it's almost hard to think of them seperately (almost like Kill Bill Vol. 1 and 2). But anyway...
1 - New Hope - This one started it all, and even with the limited budget it was amazing. We're introduced to almost all the important characters in the Star Wars trilogy (minus the emperor, yoda, boba fett, and lando of course) and story has a beginning, middle and end.
Negatives: "These blaster marks are too accurate for sand people"...but those imperial troops that can never hit anything could make those shots? Ha! Umm...not too much else I can complain about. Unless of course we want to talk about the physics problems (but it was a galaxy far away and long ago, maybe the rules were different there)
Positives: Great story, movie stands on its own, great action, a classic all around
2 - Return of the Jedi - Some say it's cheesy, some hate the ewoks, but I love it. It has the great Jabba scenes (Rancor!), the fantastically layered ending (3 major plotlines overlapping at once), and the great struggle between Luke and Vader (and Vader and Vader).
Negatives: Ewoks are too cute and cuddly (still better than Jar Jar), Yoda dies, Boba Fett dies.
Positives: Great battle scenes, lots of memorable worlds and returning/new characters, Lando kicks ass.
3 - Empire Strikes Back - Yes, every snob says that this was the best of all. It had drama, sadness, Luke vs. Vader part I, the hand, the father, carbonite, etc. But if we're taking these films seperate this one has the hardest time standing alone I think. Yeah people like the downer ending, but much like the 2nd Matrix film, it not only leaves room for a third, but it makes a third film necessary. There is little if any closure. Also, with all the complaints about muppets and all why does no one ever complain about Yoda? I guess he's just too cool and above all that...
Negatives: No closure or solid end, front heavy action.
Positives: Hoth is one of the most memorable locales (and always the best stage in any Star Wars game), who doesn't love Yoda, Lando and Boba Fett show up and rock the house, dramaic end with Vader's confession, Luke's missing hand, and Han's freezing.
So there's where we are. The simple rating system puts them at IV, VI, V, III, I, II. And if I were a betting man, and I am, I'd wager that many of you out there will disagree with me (I've yet to find anyone who actually agrees with my last three, let alone all six), and you're welcome to voice your digust. I mean if you can't rant like a lunatic on the internet then where can you? Other than a NYC street corner perhaps...